Justice normative change

Indicator ID J7
Indicator full statement

# of norms, guidelines, and procedures developed and adopted in line with child-centred and gender justice standards across criminal, civil, family, religious, or community-based justice systems.

Purpose

Importance

This indicator aims to indicate the positive outcome of Tdh technical expertise provision and advocacy work, how it translates into the adoption of legally related (norms) or policy documents that support the correct application of those norms/law enforcement (guidelines and procedures).

ToC pathway
  1. Procedural safeguards are reinforced across the Child Justice Systems.

  2. Inclusive and Non-Discriminatory Access to Justice, with a focus on Gender Justice, is prioritized.

  3. Social Cohesion is enhanced through the promotion of local justice for children and youth as well as through their role as agents of change to achieve peaceful societies.

  4. Plural Justice Systems are strengthened and officially interact together.

Related services

Service Catalogue: production of information, advocacy and awareness raising.

Definition

Norm: Any law or regulation (e.g. bylaw, decrees) producing binding legal effects that could be formally approved by:

  • Legislative or executive branches at the local, national, or regional level, or

  • Supra-national governmental organization

  • As a result of an agreement between States at the international level (e.g. treaties, conventions, covenants, at bilateral or multilateral levels).

Guidelines: they provide a framework to achieve a certain policy or legislation for ensuring their effective implementation, including a training curriculum for professionals directed related to the application of a norm.

Procedures: understood as the administrative definition of the organization of the roles, functions, skills, and working relationships, between several actors working in the same field or collaborating across different sectors. The procedure is often sequenced and codified in a document (e.g. protocol), which is generally only binding for the actors involved in its implementation.

Child-centred justice standards: several documents compile those standards (e.g. the Beijing Rules, the Havana Rules, the Riyadh Guidelines, the Guidelines for Action on Children in the Criminal Justice System, the Guidelines on Justice in Matters Involving Child Victims and Witnesses of Crime, Guidance Note - UN Approach to Justice for Children). The General Comments of the Committee on the Rights of the Child are also good sources for guidance in this regard (e.g. General Comment 24 and General Comment 27). 

Gender Justice Standards as applicable to children: please refer to Tdh Gender Justice Global policy document: Inclusive Child Justice with a Gender & Diversity Approach: Turning Challenges into Progress | Terre des hommes (tdh.org)

How to collect & analyse the data

What do we count?

Number of norms, guidelines, and procedures that match the description/definitions.

How to calculate the indicator's value

Sum of norms, guidelines, and procedures that match the description/definitions. Please, disaggregate by geographical scope: local/national.

Data sources

Project data, the norm/guidelines/procedures published on any official website.

Data collection methods and tools

Document review.

Disaggregation

Level of change : local, national, regional, global.

Limitations and precautions

This indicator is not intended to measure the impact on children of the positive changes in the standards, laws, and/or policies that Tdh has managed to influence positively through the development of norms, guidelines, and policies. It aims at demonstrating the concrete results of Tdh's actions on executive and legislative processes.

  • The official approval of legal reform and law enforcement documents is usually slow. This quantitative indicator does not capture only the end product but also all the efforts deployed by Tdh in terms of technical work on norms, guidelines, and procedures, even if not yet officially approved. Make sure to be specific about those efforts when reporting this indicator.

  • The involvement of Tdh in law reform and law enforcement may vary a lot according to the context and many contextual factors may interfere positively or negatively in the development and adoption process. Make sure to highlight what was Tdh's direct contribution/influence in the process in your analysis.

  • The end product might only partially be aligned with child-centred and gender justice principles.  Make sure that the analysis includes a reflection on the limits and strengths of the normative and guidance/procedures pieces of the work concerned.

What further analysis are we interested in?

  • What are the limits and strengths of the normative piece of work concerned?

  • What is the cause-and-effect relationship between the actions of Tdh and the positions of public authorities towards them?

To do this, a comparative exercise between the pre and post situations and the changes that the norm, guideline, or procedure are intended to create as expressed by those public authorities (i.e rationale of the document produced for instance if it is a document to align national legislation with international standards, national commitments made by the public authorities).

Additional guidance

See references above.

This guidance was prepared by Tdh ©
Propose Improvements